Mascara is an absolute must for me when it comes to makeup, and I rarely leave the house without it. Recently, I’ve learned how many unnecessary toxins are in commercial mascara – and while they may give the desired effect, they aren’t the best alternative for our lashes or our environment.
Here at Trash Backwards, we are heavy advocates for all things zero-waste and cruelty-free. And while we understand the challenges of going completely plastic-free, we also know that there are so many sustainable options out there that end up being cheaper in the long run and even better quality!
This goes for zero-waste mascara too.
So, let’s upgrade your makeup bag with some of the top zero-waste mascaras for beautiful lashes!
This post contains affiliate links which may earn us a small commission at no cost to you.
#1 Nudi Goods
Starting off our list we have the all-natural mascara by Nudi Goods.
The mascara is only created out of 5 ingredients which are: Activated Charcoal, Beeswax, Shea Butter, and Bentonite Clay. While the mascara is not entirely vegan, it’s cruelty-free and environmentally safe to use.
There are also 3 shades you can choose from, Black, Dark Brown, and Brown, with Dark Brown being the most popular option!
Best of all,
The Nudi Good mascara arrives in a reusable metal tin with an applicator spoolie, making it a truly zero-waste product!
#2 Home Sweet By Aleida
I like using mascaras that give me the length and volume I desire and improve my overall eyelash health too!
You’ll be happy to know that this is exactly what you can expect from the mascara collection by Home Sweet By Aleida.
According to this study conducted by Science Direct, the product is enriched with castor oil, which is proven to make our eyelashes grow better and healthier in the long run. On top of that, the mascara is entirely cruelty-free, paraben-free, and contains no unnecessary toxins or chemicals.
You’ll also be presented with 3 color options to suit your preference, such as Dark Brown, Brown, and Black. Plus, the mascara arrives in a reusable aluminum tin with a bamboo brush.
#3 Dab Herb Makeup
Have you ever heard of organic powder mascara?
Dab Herb’s aloe vera enriched mascara is not only good for our environment, but they contain all the good stuff for our lashes, too!
What puts some customers off is the process of using this type of product. However, once you get the hang of it, it’s actually pretty easy, and it allows you to play with the consistency to match your preference.
All you need to do is mix the powder with the included eye serum to make it into a paste. Afterward, you’ll use the bamboo wand to apply the mixture to your eyelashes brows, or you can even use it as eyeliner.
The mascara powder and serum contain no parabens, glycols, silicones, or heavy metals. Additionally, the product arrives in a cute golden aluminum case that you can bring anywhere.
#4 RAW Beauty LLC Natural Mascara
The RAW Beauty LLC Natural Mascara might be closer to what most of us think of when we use mascara. It comes in a plastic tube (which we aren’t a fan of) – but the product itself is pretty great and, best of all, cruelty-free.
However, Raw Beauty does have a zero-waste option, which comes in glass-shaped tin – it may be messier, but it’s a lot more sustainable!
This formula is also quick drying and contains castor oil for healthier eyelashes. Other ingredients include Candelilla Wax, Glycerin, Carnauba Wax, Distilled Water, and Iron Oxide.
Lastly, you can choose between 2 tones: Brown or Black.
#5 Sweet Leilani
The Sweet LeiLani’s mascara will not only provide your lashes with excellent volume and length but nourish them too. The formula is enriched with Coconut oil, Provitamin B5, Grapeseed oils, and Green Tea – all of which will promote healthier and glossier lashes in the long run.
The mascara doesn’t contain any toxic ingredients and doesn’t contain any palm oil either. The formula is also cruelty-free and vegan, and of course, zero-waste. The mascara is stored in a recyclable card stock tube with an inner straw lining.
Last update on 2023-09-24 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
#6 Beeyou Organics
BeeYou Organics has a wonderful shop selling many natural organic products, all of which are cruelty-free, including their zero-waste mascaras.
The mascaras are made up of only 5 ingredients, including organic charcoal, making your eyelashes look great and promoting lash growth. The formula is also free from any oxides, parabens, and phthalates.
The mascaras come in glass tubes, and you can request the seller to leave out the reusable mascara wand if you already have one.
#7 Dirty Hippie Cosmetics
Dirty Hippie also has a variety of handmade and organic products on their page, including 2 types of mascaras – lengthening and volumizing.
I also like that the mascara arrives in a recyclable glass tube which you can get refilled if you reside in Australia.
The mascara is also enriched with beneficial ingredients such as essential oils and vitamins E and B5 for optimal lash growth. You can choose from 2 different color tones, carbon black or cacao brown.
#8 Clean-Faced Cosmetics
The Clean-Faced Cosmetics mascara might be the winner on our list for various reasons. Number one being that their mascara is composed of only 4 ingredients – Castor Oil, Charcoal, Candelilla Wax, and Kaolin!
I also like that the mascaras come in more color options: clear, black, white, brown, and more.
Additionally, since the mascara is oil-based, you won’t need to mix it with water or moisten the brush before use. It also won’t be as clumpy and drying as other natural brands.
#9 Muschel Cosmetics
The Muschel Cosmetics mascara and eyebrow gel is the most unique and zero-waste product on this list.
The mascara arrives in a little wax nugget form – it doesn’t get more zero-waste than that!
To use it, simply use a knife to scrape off the top or slice in the middle to expose the inside product, which you apply to your eyebrows or lashes using a reusable bamboo wand or spoolie. The whole concept is very innovative, and it’s pretty travel-friendly, too.
The ingredients are also very nourishing and include Castor oil, Seed Butter, Coconut oil, Vitamin E, etc. Plus, the product contains no preservatives and is hypoallergenic.
We hope that you enjoyed our list of the top zero-waste mascaras. Are there any brands we missed out on? Let us know in the comments below, and thanks for reading!
If you want to pair your beautiful lashes with ultra-soft and kissable lips this summer, check out our 9 best zero-waste lip balms, too!
Anna Miller is a content manager at TrashBackwards. She’s passionate about living a zero-waste lifestyle. Anna has been writing about eco-friendly tips for years now, and she’s got some great ideas on how you can go plastic-free! She loves sharing her knowledge about eco-lifestyle with others. Her articles are always witty and insightful! Shoot her a message if you’ve got any questions about how you can start going green.